Pennelopy's Pizzaria

Write a Review920-849-3043

OPEN NOW - Closes at 9:00pm

Years ago, at their old location, their food was delicious and always fresh. The staff was friendly, and the atmosphere was family-like.



At their new location, the food is never fresh and the staff is just as stale. The manager is super rude and carefree about the business. She could care less that the food is old. Most of the food has a film over it. The pizza is like cardboard, as it has been sitting out long past it's state-required pull date. A health inspector needs to make a surprise visit. The mashed potatoes on the buffet are brown and crusty, the gravy is thick and lumpy. The lettuce on the salad bar as brown and slimy.



I have tried this place twice in the last month, just in case they had a bad day. Sadly, the food sucks now. I want the old owners from years ago back!

The food was terrible! The chicken was not fully cooked and there was a hair in my salad. They still made me pay for my meal even though I had only ate about 2 bites. Oh, the consolidation was that they gave me. $2 off. Find another restaurant to eat at!

Haven't been to the old restaurant but the new restaurant is the same. Very poor service, food okay.

Not sure how the new place will be, but the old one was NOT good!!! The buffet was NEVER fresh and the workers are not friendly!!! I will give them a try ONE more time when they open again... otherwise we will not be returning!