Are you craving authentic New York City pizza? You don’t have to travel far to get that taste you love. Come to The Original Bizzarro Famous N Y Pizza in Indialantic, Fla., for the best in quality pizza and Italian cuisine. From antipasto to large pies, we have the delicious, mouthwatering dishes you’re looking for, all at affordable prices. From the smell of our simmering sauce, to our warm, family style atmosphere, we know that you’ll feel right at home with us. Come in today to order your favorite slice. Serving Indiatlantic, Melbourne, Melbourne Beach, Palm Bay, Eau Galle and Indian Harbor.
Hi there!
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate

Reviews

GS
Ga S.

07/30/2017

Provided by YP.com

We ordered 2 large pizza for carry out and I was very disappointed in the pizza crust and customer service. This was by far the worst pizza crust that I have had in a very long time...years to be exact. It was beyond limp to the point it was soggy. I am not sure if the crust was not cooked long enough or if the toppings caused the excess moisture but there was liquid under the crust. Needless to say I will never order from there again or any other Bizzarro's for that matter.. There are plenty of good pizzas out there and in fact those from the grocery store freezer section are better. I hope this is not typical NY pizza. I ordered ahead and did not like having to wait in line while other guests placed there orders. The atmosphere was loud. I guess people will eat anything to be out on the ocean.

PC
Patty C.

07/25/2015

Provided by YPmobile

Cash only, unruly kids everywhere and dry pizza slices. Will never go back.

LJ
Lori-ann J.

07/08/2014

Provided by YPmobile
Great Sicilian!

High & light dough with crispy crust and the good the Mozzarella! Perfect great job fellas!

ML
Malka L.

07/03/2014

Provided by YP.com

Average pizza. Definitively not 'gourmet'. Will not go back

RJ
R J.

01/26/2014

Provided by YP.com

This is absolutely the worst pizza we have ever had, If it is called NY pizza it must be the crap sold in NYC, it is much worse than even the poorest pizzas made in Western NY state (the other NY). Blizzaro pizza crust is cardboard thin, too tough to chew with the same flavor as the takeout box. You cannot hold a slice in your hand without it folding like a wet sheet of paper. The sauce tastes ketchup with no spices. Pepperoni is supermarket type - thin slices, bland flavor. The dogs would not eat the 3/4 pizza we threw out. Seriously, we have never had such bad pizza, not even in Florida, not even at Dumpinoe's. Rated it 1 star because it wouldn't take 0.

C
cunetta1

09/11/2010

Provided by YP.com
The BEST in Florida

WE just moved here from NY, and we never thought we would find pizza as great as you get there. But we were wrong. Bizzarro,s is truly NY pizza! They make it to perfection! A

M
mobo688

02/06/2008

Provided by YP.com
Killer slices.

Awesome, huge slices of NY style pizza. Nothing beats a hot slice and a cold beer.

More Business Info

Hours
Regular Hours
Mon - Sat:
Sun:
Payment method
cash only
Price Range
$
Location
AT THE BOARDWALK
Neighborhood
Indialantic by The Sea
Amenities
Indoor or Patio Dining Eat in or Take Out
AKA

The Original Bizzarro Famous N Y Piz

Categories
Pizza, Restaurant Menus, Restaurants
Other Information

Parking: Street

Wi-Fi: No

Bike Parking: Yes

Wheelchair Accessible: Yes

Take Out: Yes

Cuisines: Pizza

Takes Reservations: No

Outdoor Seating: Yes

Price Range : Below Average