New York Pizzeria

Write a Review910-938-2201

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 10:00am

horrible pizza. gross. ordered a pie. The worst pizza i ever had. Used to be the best. Now the worst. Even little caesars is better.

TW owner WROTE: Ok, I'm from South Jersey and I look forward to going back home to have real pizza, not Dominos or Pizza Hut, or even Pizza City. A slice of pizza should be so big you have to hold it with both hands and grease should be dripping off of it! This pizza is as close as I'm going to get and I think it is great. I am willing to pay for it too! Yes, I could get probably 4 pizzas from Dominos for this price; but why, it's horrible! You get what you pay for!First, he's NOT from South Jersey... Born right here in Jacksonville. Do you want food that's been dropped on the floor and then "served" to a customer? Do you want rotten lettuce in your salad? This place is just "nasty"!!! Save your hard earned money and go to Tony's in the mall, or Michaelangelo's. Now that's a real New York style pizza.

best damn pizza place in jville

The price is average and the all you can eat buffet is a great deal. The pizza is thin crust and delicious. They also deliver salads subs and spagetti. Great for air station marines

Ok, I'm from South Jersey and I look forward to going back home to have real pizza, not Dominos or Pizza Hut, or even Pizza City. A slice of pizza should be so big you have to hold it with both hands and grease should be dripping off of it! This pizza is as close as I'm going to get and I think it is great. I am willing to pay for it too! Yes, I could get probably 4 pizzas from Dominos for this price; but why, it's horrible! You get what you pay for!

Way too high. PLEASE go to Pizza City for the best pizza for a reasonable priced pizza!!!

Wow, amazing that people complain about paying for good food in this town. If you want to pay NY prices, go there! Quit complaining, the food in this town plain sucks, but these people have nailed it on the head. I have been going there on and off for over 17 years, and I have been impressed.

The pizza was good and I would expect to pay that much, if I was actually IN NEW YORK... Way overpriced.

The pizza was good and I would expect to pay that much, if I was actually IN NEW YORK... Way overpriced.

i ordered a small pizza with 2 toppings and it was 18.97 and it should of been 11.75 for pizza plus 4.00 for toppings how did they get 18.97?

The pizza was not worth the box it was served in. It was tough, tasted like the fridge, and expensive. The pizza was so tough I couldn't cut it with a butter knife it took a steak knife. On the other hand the Tiramisu was really good, considering. I would not recommend this place for pizza. It's going to be worth the 5-10 minute drive to Jacksonville Mall on Western Blvd., and order pizza from Tony's Pizza in the mall. The pizza there is always fresh, tender, and steaming hot! The best part is it really tastes like a pizza.