Mama Teresa's Italian Restaurant and Pizza

Write a Review203-877-5108

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 11:00am

Good food. Our server Annie was awesome.

As usual, my entire family and I have enjoyed another great meal here at Mama Teresa's! You don't have to go to New Haven to get great pizza! We also love that you can oder online from your mobile phone. We'll be back again soon.

I travel all throughout the state of CT for my job and have explored many italian restaurants in the state. By far, Mama Teresa's restaurant is a favorite of mine. It has a great casual, family atmosphere and they have excellent food. The penne ala vodka, eggplant parmigiana and chicken dishes are some of my favorites. They also have excellent pizza- the crust is perfect and the pizza is cooked through, unlike most places. Great place to bring your family!

this is not a place for someone with OCD , since the plates have things incrusted on them , and me and my mother saw 3 grey hairs on the pizza a few years back. The staff is mean and short , and the teen waiters, and waitresses have attitutudes like dont bother me i wanna text. The pizza itself isnt bad but keep in mind its a dark cold atmosphere.

The owner of this restaurant is extremely rude and uses misleading offers to attract customers. They have been advertising a buy one pizza, get one pizza half off promotion (higher price prevails). They however do not tell you that they will only discount one pizza regardless of the number ordered. When I questioned why only one pizza was discounted on my bill after purchasing 4, I was told that the offer states "some restrictions apply". What was most bothersome was the flip way the owner responded to my questioning the bill. Lets be honest in the same amount of space they could have easily written "only one discounted pie per table". Next time I will go to Reno's in Orange instead - they too have great pizza.

Excellent quality crust with good toppings. One of the few pizzas whose sauce contains no onions or garlic - a boon for those of us with allergies.