Fattoni's Italian/American Deli & Catering

Write a Review414-479-9840

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 9:00am

Tony Mandella returns to Wauwatosa as chef and owner of Fattoni’s Italian/American Deli & Catering in the historic Arcade Building, sharing his legendary Italian beef, meatballs and slow-roasted pork.  The deli offers hand-seasoned meats sliced to order, a great selection of cheeses, plus a deli case filled with specialties like Italian coleslaw, chicken salad made from scratch, seasonal fruits and vegetables, and more.

Check out the monthly menu for a calendar of restaurant quality entrée specials, comforting soups, and satisfying chili. Perfect for busy folks on-the-go who want fresh, healthy choices you can feel good about, and multi-tasking moms who need to get dinner on the table fast!

Convenient frozen entrées, pizzas and soups let you plan ahead and enjoy “home-made” on your schedule. A popular Sunday tradition! Enjoy hot ham and rolls for an easy lunch or to satisfy hungry Packer fans for the big game.

Call-ahead for larger orders for quick and easy entertaining. And for an added bonus –cinnamon rolls baked fresh on Sundays, too! Take a look at Fattoni’s catering options for box lunches and party platters . Pick up and delivery options are available.

Chef Tony brings his expertise to full service catering requests for weddings, business meetings, fundraisers and special occasions. Menu items may be ordered from a suggested list of catering options, or personally customized for any event.  

Hot sandwiches featured Tuesday through Saturday include Chef Tony’s Italian beef, meatball, and slow-roasted pork. Made-to-order deli sandwiches available daily. Healthy and delicious hand-made garden, oriental and spinach salads. A sweet ending for any meal…fresh-baked cookies and brownies!