Fantasy Diamonds

Write a Review212-302-2001

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 10:00am

Beware of this business. I hired them to make a setting for my stone as an engagement ring. However, the setting they made had obvious defects. It was missing metal and had dents, chips, and uneven prongs.

When I went back to the store they denied any responsibility and accused me of damaging the setting.

In addition to the poor craftsmanship, the store promised the setting would be “custom-made” to fit my stone, but when I got it inspected by an appraiser he confirmed that was not the case. Instead, the gem was jammed into a setting they already had instead of making a new one.

Any reputable jewelry store would have ensured the settings they ordered were well-made and up to customer’s liking. Not pass off a defective product, lay the blame on the customer, and deny responsibility.

Your engagement should be one of the happiest times but what a terrible experience this has been. It’s so heartbreaking when I look at my ring I don’t feel happy, only sad and frustrated.

Warning! Warning! If I was you I would look for a different dealer. I bought a diamond from Rodi. When I got home I had it appraised and found out it had been filled and enhanced. He will say he stated this but I have a witness that knows he did not. Others have contacted me with similar experiences.

BEST ON THE BLOCK YOU CANNOT GO WRONG! Most honest, easy going, informative purchase I've ever made! THANK YOU DAVID AND RODI!! WE WILL BE BACK SOON!

Best in the business, nothing but QUALITY sold here! Great experience, these guys will go above and beyond to keep a customer. They even let you name your price. A variety of quality stones to chose from. Thank you Daniel, see soon for my upgrade!

LOVE! LOVE! LOVE! this place!!! Bought a pair of diamond studs for my daughters 16th birthday and she loved them! The owners David and Rodi were so nice and really helped me choose the right pair! Will defiantly be coming back here! Thanks again! :)

Wow! Came to 47th street with my husband hoping to upgrade my ring with a budget in mind. . . David & Rodi were so accomodating! They showed me a setting and a stone that I fell in love with and worked with us on the price since it was a little over our initial budget. Needless to say, we left VERY happy customers. We have already gone back to get earrings for our daughter and a watch for our son. Definitely the best on the block! Very attentive and very informative. Pleasure to work with each and every time!

Bought a pair of diamond studs from David and Rodi.. Their level of professionalism and customer service is above and beyond. When i called them to let them know i lost the back off one of my earrings they were quick to send out a new pair (all the way to Texas!!) free of charge! Will definatley purchase from here again anytime i need anything! Thanks again boys

If you want to be charged $50 for a $12 battery replacement after you hand them your watch, then this is the place for you. I was surprised at the level of dishonesty and poor service, considering I handed them a $1000 watch. Robi the owner was very convinced, that despite not offering me a ticket and giving me an initial two hour wait time, for a 15 minute job, that I should have been appreciative of the 'deal' that I was given. In the end I paid $30, because they don't accept credit cards allegedly. Hmm. There won't be a repeat trip.