Dominick's Pizzeria

Write a Review973-383-9330

OPEN NOW - Closes at 10:00pm

Food is delicious the service is excellent

In all the years we have been coming here, never a bad meal. The best sauce in Sussex County. Prices very reasonable and they remember your name!

Best pizza around!! Fast, courteous service. Treats every customer as though they're special. Highly recommended.

Delivered on time. Pizza was great a couple of times, but doughy and undercooked last time.

We would order from them again, but we would mention to make sure it is crispy.

Food is inconsistent at best. When I order pizza for takeout, I find the pizza is often overdone - sometimes burned. I find there is too much socializing among people that work there, including the owner, so the customer is always second. While getting takeout, there have been many times where I've tried to order a drink or something extra and I've been totally ignored. So they end up losing a sale and they don't even know it! It's gotten to the point where I won't even go to order a pizza anymore. As for dining in, things are a bit better. However, the food is still inconsistent. Sometimes it's great other times it's mediocre. The owner needs to get a clue, but I doubt that'll ever happen. Too bad because it has great potential. (If you want great pizza in the Newton area, go to Villa Capri.)

I must start by saying that their food is very good. Owner seems to have a propensity to hire young good looking girls. Basically paying them to hang out with him and to have something to look at. Prices are much more then one should pay for flower, water, tomato sauce, and cheese (unless I was over charged by one of the blonde geniuses). However the food is very good for Sussex county.

I am increasingly disappointed with the food and customer service as its quality has deteriorated over the many years. The owners are appear to be less concerned with quality on all measures, but overly concerned with tall, thin, blonds. So, if you are tall, thin, and blond, enjoy the service, and if your not-lower your expectations because that's the only way you'll walk out feeling satisfied.

I went in there to get pizza becasue i know the guy and he said " do not come in here anymore" so whatever you do, do not "NEVER GO THERE"