Tomato Pie

Write a Review765-537-9000

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 11:00am

So far we have tried the stromboli, and the carnivour pizza. Both were amazing.

Im a pizzaholic......this is the best Ive EVER had!

This place is less than friendly. Not very many smiles, and no voice to welcome you when you walk in. If you take this and the other prices of pizza into thought, this would be the LAST place I would buy pizza from. I'd rather drive 10 miles and be welcomed by a friendly face and voice than buy at this place to a sour puss and less than friendly greeting. Too expensive and the prices SUCK for the taste.

Great pizza, Great place, You get your moneys worth and you will leave full and satisfied.

This is the best pizza around... You must try it you will be hooked !!

Oh my goodness, everyone needs to try this place! Their pizzas are loaded to the max and the breadsticks are just bursting with flavor! Just thinking about Tomatoe Pie makes my mouth water. Oh and they also have the best service. The lady who owns it is just awesome! We called her one night and told her that we would like to have a steak and cheese pizza, it wasn't on the menu but she made us one anyway and it was absolutley delicious. She always has a smile on her face and even remembers our name when we come in. This lady goes the extra mile to make her customers happy and we will not go to any other pizza place as long as Tomatoe Pie is around. If hane not tried this place then you are missing out on some of greatest pizza ever made! So what are you waiting for? Go satisfy you tastebuds at Tomatoe Pie!

Do you know how long I have been looking for great pizza here in Indiana? Well for a very long time. Guess what? I have finally found it! Tomato Pie in Paragon. You have to go and try a slice for yourself. This place is not advertising much, just word of mouth (no pun intended), and it is working! The word is getting out, this is great pizza. When I want pizza, this is my stop. Breadsticks, Awesome, best I have had. I believe the owner was originally from Paragon and has come home and brought a great tasting pizza with her. Don't delay Go!

We live on the southside of Indianapolis and regularly make the trip to Paragon just to get Tomatoe Pie pizza. Lots of toppings, the sauce is excellent and it's one of the only pizza crusts I will eat when the toppings are all gone. The twisted breadsticks are excellent with lots of herbal flavor. If this place was closer to Indy the owner would be a millionaire. I recommend this place to all my friends and drag them along every chance we get.