History: Now occupied by the Gay 90's Pizza Company, this 1864 building was one of the first commercial buildings in town. It originally housed a general store, bar and Wells Fargo stagecoach stop. The upper floor housed a brothel for many years, and some Pleasanton residents have reported seeing a full-figured ghost lady in the front second story window. Chinese laborers constructed a connection to the town's underground tunnels. Welcome: We hope you enjoy your visit here at the Gay Nineties web site. Feel free to roam around and learn more about what we have to offer. If you have any questions, feel free to contact us. At Gay Nineties, we make great tasting pizzas from scratch and are famous for our sour dough specialty pizzas. We have won Best Pizza from the Tri-Valley Herald since 1997! We are also a National Restaurant Association award winner. For a complete dining experience, don't hesitate to consider us, Gay Nineties. Reservations: Reservations are availabl e every day for lunch and Monday-Thursday for dinner. Reservations and orders can be made seven days a week during operation hours.
Hi there!
Rate this business!
First-classBetter than mostAbout what I expectedNot the worst...Disappointing
Click to Rate

Reviews

AW
Austin W.

08/22/2023

Provided by YP.com

We love coming down here for the pepperoni pizza one of my favorite top three pizza places in the area also they have very friendly staff and great service

NB
Nikola B.

07/31/2023

Provided by YP.com

Just had one of my favorite new pepperoni pizza I've ever had highly recommend this pizza joint to anyone who is a pizza lover.

SE
Sal E.

12/14/2022

Provided by YP.com

Great service all around great food. Loved it
I’m from Sanger ca and when I’m up north
I stop in there luv this restaurant. 5 star for me.

Beth W.

03/31/2016

Provided by YPmobile

All time favorite pizza! A Pleasanton must. The old-fashioned, cozy atmosphere adds to the experience.

Dennis T.

03/26/2016

Provided by YPmobile

Best pizza ever. The food is great all around. The beer is cold and fresh. The people are nice and welcoming. I always stop by when I'm in town

Dennis T.

03/26/2016

Provided by YPmobile

5 star and then some best pizza in an awesome location. The place has been there forever and the food is great. The beer is xtra cold and sit outside of you can.

BC
Blast C.

10/03/2015

Provided by YPmobile

Worst service ever!spent $158. The watress sucked ignored us whole time.she spilled coke on my leg.didnt get our order right had to tell her 2 times to get a salad.and didn't refill our coke till 2 hours later only to have it spilled on me.never go there again!avoid the braizian watress.i want my money back.

WS
Wayne S.

09/07/2015

Provided by YP.com

We were just back after seeing the Darlingside at the Firehouse Arts Center...best service, we were really, really late and were served the best pizza, wayne'sworld and the service was fantastic. Staff treated us like welcomed family. Worth the drive from Fremont if I want a pizza.

L
lb5285

10/11/2010

Provided by YP.com
Not like the old Days!

I grew up at this place. The pizza is still good but not like it used to be. I do still like the atmosphere.

W
wonder83

12/05/2009

Provided by YP.com
Good with a great atmosphere!

I love this place for the atmosphere! The pizza is good but not as good as it used to be years ago. They have things other than pizza that are good also.

J
jatmataga

07/29/2009

Provided by YP.com
so so

i ried it for the first time today since i seen all these good reviews and the pizza was alright it seems like there dough wasnt cooked all the way and the red sauce is a fast heartburn ready to happend

T
telles4

07/12/2008

Provided by YP.com
Heaven

One of the best pizza places I have ever been to. Pizza is the best

H
halay001

01/25/2008

Provided by YP.com
Like the outdoor dining

Love dining on the patio in the summer...great place to enjoy a pizza and a brew. Pizza's not the best though...but not bad.

More Business Info

Won "Best Pizza" from TriValley Herald Since 1997

Hours
Regular Hours
Mon - Thu:
Fri - Sat:
Sun:
Services/Products
Dinner Lunch
Payment method
discover, visa, amex, mastercard
Price Range
$
Amenities
Hand-Tossed Pizza; Catering & Take Out Available; Full Service Restaurant; Reservations Available; Open 7 Days
Social Links
Categories
Pizza, American Restaurants, Family Style Restaurants, Italian Restaurants, Restaurants, Take Out Restaurants
Other Information

Wheelchair Accessible: Yes

Cuisines: Pizza

Banner
Suggest an Edit