Sals Pizza Portage

Write a Review608-745-9955

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 11:00am

I called Sal's to find out if they had an online menu. I was told by the girl that answered the phone to check out the menu for the Sal's in Appleton and they could make whatever was on their menu. She said the prices may be a little different.
I checked out the menu and decided to go with a large 18" Bacon Cheeseburger pizza, 2 gyros and 12 wings. When I called Sal's in Portage to place the order, I was told they only had 8, 16 or more of the chicken wings. So I ordered 16, half plain and half BBQ along with the gyros and the pizza. I was told my order amount was $52 which I thought was a little expensive, considering the pizza on the Appleton site was $19.95. I was told it was $24. Well it was raining and late so I placed the order. It took 40 minutes to get which I didn't think was bad. When I opened up the pizza, half the cheese was stuck to the cardboard. The driver said he would take it back and have another made. I felt sorry for him and said it was ok and we would just scrape it off the box.
Well, the food was not worth the price. The pizza was a far cry from being a Bacon Cheeseburger. It was more like a Cheese pizza. We could find any bacon on the pizza and there was very little "burger" meat. The gyros were so-so. The cucumber sauce was more like sour cream and flavorless. I must say the meat was tender but that was the only good thing about them. The wings were nothing out of the ordinary.
The people eating the pizza said it wasn't a Bacon Cheeseburger pizza. I didn't know because I was having 1 of the gyros. When I did try it the next day, it was very bland and I kept trying to find the bacon and the sausage, which I never found.
I called the restaurant to complain only to be told I should be eating pizza the next day and the leftover should have been tossed. I tried to tell them after I asked what is on the Cheeseburger and they told me Sausage, Bacon, a blend of cheese and mozerella cheese. I told them again that it looked more like just a cheese pizza and I could have purchased 2 large pizzas from another establishment for less then I paid for this one and enjoyed it more. He said he was sorry and didn't do anything about it. I told them I would not order from there again and hung up. After 15 minutes I got 2 phone calls from them and neither on did they leave a message. I didn't know they had called back because I left my phone in a different room and didn't hear it.
Anyway, I'm not going to order from here ever again. It isn't worth the price nor the quality. I wouldn't ever give them one star if I could have.