Our expertly trained pharmacists and friendly staff pride themselves on making sure your pharmacy experience exceeds expectations. Visit us today and let us take care of you.

More Business Info

Where Caring People Care for You!

Business History
Bay Street Pharmacy was established in 1984 by pharmacist/owners Joe Tolle, Jr. and Frank J. Sherako. Joe also owned and operated Sebastian River Drugs in Sebastian from 1972 to 1992. Theresa Tolle, daughter-in-law of Joe, joined Bay Street Pharmacy in 1997 and became a partner in 1999. Joe retired in 2001 and Frank retired in 2005. Theresa and her husband, Joe Tolle, III, remain owners of Bay Street Pharmacy today and are proud of it's history and to continue the family tradition of serving the greater Sebastian area and fulfilling their motto, "where caring people care for you".
BBB Rating
A+
BBB Rating and Accreditation information may be delayed up to a week.
Hours
Holiday Hours
2024/01/01Closed
Holiday Hours
2024/11/28Closed
Holiday Hours
2024/07/04Closed
Holiday Hours
2024/05/27Closed
Holiday Hours
2024/12/25Closed
Holiday Hours
2024/09/02Closed
Regular Hours
Mon - Fri:
Sat:
SunClosed
Services/Products
Oxygen Equipment, Breast Forms, Mastectomy Bras, Diabetic Supplies, First Aid Supplies, Durable Medical Equipment, Rapid Flu Test, Rapid Strep Test, Covid-19 Testing (ST-PCR,rapid antigen, antibody), Paxlovid and molnupiravir, Immunizations, Greeting Cards, Unique Trinkets, Bariatric Advantage products, Vitamins, Supplements, Monthly Compliance Packaging, Medication Synchronization, Compounding for People and Pets, Free Delivery
Brands
Home Health, Oxygen
Payment method
debit, check, cash, all major credit cards, insurance
Location
Across from Sebastian River Medical Center on US1 in Sebastian
Languages
English, Spanish
Associations
Sebastian River Area Chamber of Commerce, Substance Abuse Free Indian River
Social Links
Category
Pharmacies
Suggest an Edit