Muscarella's Cafe Italia

Write a Review724-962-1234

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 11:00am

Never had a bad meal from this place. Service was excellent for the amount of customers. Definitely a diamond in the rough!

My husband and I went down on Feb 15 for his birthday to eat. We have been there several times and liked there varieties of spaghetti. We also ordered calamari and stuffed hot peppers for appetizers. The calamari was terrible. We even said something about it and they took that one back to the kitchen. The waitress brought us out another plate and it was just as bad. The calamari was like paper thin and had no taste to it. Then to find out the spaghetti portions were much smaller than they had previously been. The topping on the cake was when we got our bill and the Calamari was still on there even though we sent it back twice and did not eat hardly any of it. Service was much to be desired also. We sat without drinks for quite a while.

Best kept secret in Sharpsville. Italian at its best.

I absolutely love the food at Muscarella's. They have hefty portions cooked to perfection. There service leaves much more than is desired. The only time I have had appropriate service we sat in the bar area and were served by a younger male bartender. I have experienced serving and am sensitive to how hard that job can be. Please hire some waitresses with personality and class.

Wonderful atmosphere, wide variety of choices, great lunch specials, very good service. I recommend the meatball splash, but anything Italian here is good.

I love the food and the atmosphere here. The service is great. The prices are very reasonable.

Fine food, local people enjoy the atmosphere.