Nicky's

Write a Review920-457-6425

OPEN NOW - Closes at 10:00pm

Pizza beyond belief - Prices are great - super value for all food! Perfect crust! Great toppings! Been going to Nicky's for 30 years and it's still SUPER GREAT - THE BEST!

Nicky's Pizza makes a fantastic pie! From their hand-tossed crust, beautifully seasoned sauce, and mouth watering mozzarella to the always friendly, attentive staff, Nicky's Pizza is THE classic mom-and-pop pizzeria. And you can't beat their convenient, city-central location and free delivery. Nicky's has it going on!

We ordered a pie last weekend for delivery. We ordered a "The Sheboygan" which should have had Italian sausage, pepperoni and double cheese. I also ordered mushrooms and onions on half of the pie. We waited for 45 minutes which was ok but, when we opened the wrapper after the driver had left, we found NO PEPPERONI and MANY mushrooms and onions all over the pie. My wife hates both and ate very little. This was too late and we weren't about to wait another 45 min for another pie as we were starving. So, check your pie BEFORE the driver leaves!

LOVE nicky's Pizza!!! wouldn't change a thing!!, always friendly service and great food. Cut little dining room and fun to watch whats going on in the kitcken through the windows - looks like they're havin fun, hey, maybe they're hiring!!! I could eat there pizza everyday, the price is reasonable and the pizza is huge!!

I love nicky's pizza - BEST in town by far! The service is always friendly, I love the way the employees interact through the kitchen windows, you can see how crazy buisy it gets, but it looks like they are having fun, they were spinning the crust and having fun with the kids in the diningroom. I've always had great service and great food there!! Maybe the other reviewer just caught a new person on the job, heavens knows its hard to keep good help, although I have seen alot of the same faces over the years.

The food was worth a 4star as Pizza goes always great well once a hair over cooked but still Great. But service a 1 star at best No one knew what the heck they where doing I called ahead told the girl I had a coupon even went over it with her twice just in case NO still screwed it up . Had to wait because they had to call owner because they never saw coupon before and then got home and find no blue cheese with the wing. Its to the point with service WHICH I am paying for I dont want to go back not worth it to have to deal with it NOT the first time this happened there with things messed up. To top it off dont even say hey we messed up how about a coupon for a buck off or what ever Getting SAD nickys better step in up a notch.