Sarah Street Grill

Write a Review570-424-9120

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 4:00pm

we.arrived on a Monday around.4:30. the entrance area is adjacent to the bar, which reeked like stale beer. it's ok for a bar to stench like that after a busy Saturday night, but not early Monday evening. we were seated upstairs in a dimly lit room with only one other table was.all ready Sat, this was a couple who were having g.some sort of serious discussion. we knew this because we were seated directly next to them despite the dozen or so unoccupied tables in the room. when the server came to take our order, I was asked how did I want the pork chop special cooked. I replied in a cast iron pan, as it was.advertised as "blackened", she clarified what.she ment but ask I g what temperature I wanted my pork.cooked. I told her that since there was a SERVE SAFE managers.certificate displayed on the premises, I trusted chef to have it cooked properly. during my 45-50 minute wait. a manager came.by our.table twice to ask how.we.we're.doing. unfortunately he didn't notice the conspicuous absence of food, nor the empty glasses on our table. the meanwhile, the couple next to us received several plates.of.sushi while we.we're wishing we had some.bread to keep us occupied. eventually our food came. the pork chop was RARE.when I cut along the bone, the interior was COLD TO THE TOUCH! the sauteed spinach might have been tasty, but the VERY UNDERCOOKED PORK.CHOP.was.placed.directly on it and was BLEEDING PINK all over my spinach and potatos. the manager who came.by twice when we had no food was.nowhere to be had when we needed him. my companions were not thrilled with their food either. we will not be back!

We went there yesterday for a graduation celebration. It started off slow by not seeing our waitress for a solid 15 minutes but after that she was around and was a great help. Overall the service was pretty good. As for the food, we ordered several appetizers. The buffalo wings were really good! The actual meals we had varied. One of the people in our party got a burger which they said was awesome. Another two people got Reuben sandwiches which the meat was burnt ad tasted more like beef jerky than corned beef. I ordered a buffalo Cajun chicken sandwich. It was supposed to be fried and crispy per the menu description... Came out neither one of those and way over seasoned. The meat itself tasted like it was a frozen piece of chicken, so you could taste the lack of freshness. Overall I would take this place for what it is... A sports bar as just go for wings and burgers and you'll have a good meal, but stray too far from that and you won't be enjoying yourself.