Brooklyn Pizza

Write a Review850-224-5454

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 10:15am

This place has the worst pizza I have ever had in Tallahassee. The meats are very poor quality and very little put on the pizzas. They use canned mushrooms where others use fresh ones. The pizzas are loaded with grease which leaks thru the crust. Even the cheese tastes like imitation cheese. The final complaint is the high cost of the poor quality pizza. $14.95 for a large specialty pizza with scant toppings is ridiculous. Bypass this place and go to Pizza Hut or Godfathers. Even Hungry Howies is a better choice!

Their pizza is SOOO AMAZINGGG! They just opened up a new place in rahway, NJ. It's bangingggggg! I usually eat a whole pie to myself, the feta cheese and green peppers as a topping on the pizza taste great together. These boys from europe really know how to make pizza!

Great! I would reccomend this place to anyone.



Just overall fantastic.

Brooklyn is the best New York Style pizza in town! Make sure you get an order of garlic knots to go along with your pizza! The Italian salad is also a good choice and their subs are huge and on great garlic bread. But nothing beats their pizza. They have lunch specials with slices, two for one domestic beer specials and different pizza specials throughout the week. Definitely worth a try, especially over the chain pizza in town!

This place is sooo good. I swear they put something addictive in it, because I'm always craving their food. Yummy, beats MoMos and all those other places.

Brooklyn Pizza is the best in Tally. I'm addicted!