Make Believin' Costumes

Write a Review717-741-3600

CLOSED NOW - Opens at 10:00am

They have amazing costumes there, they make a lot of themselves, very unique! They are also open extended hours in October, Monday thru Saturday 10-8 (not like in the listing). Really worth checking out!

I called a couple days ago and asked if they have a particular item in stock. The associate who answered the phone said that she would have to check the warehouse and call me back. I gave her my name and number. She never called me back. It's a shame because if she would have called me back my boyfriend and I would have both bought costumes from Make Believin'. Her not calling me back showed me that the shop does not care about its customers so my boyfriend and I wound up buying costumes from Amazon instead.

I love this shop! I've rented and purchased many costumes and pieces from these good folks over the years and I always come away with great suggestions, ideas, tips and always a great experience! I may worry about getting to my party on time, or what food item I'm going to bring, but I never worry about my costume from Make Believin'.